Skip to main content
advance-directives

What to Put in a Living Will: Life Support, Tube Feeding

Sam DaltonOctober 29, 20267 min read
What to Put in a Living Will: Life Support, Tube Feeding

A Living Will, the instructions part of an Advance Healthcare Directive, records your choices about life-prolonging treatment, tube feeding, and organ donation. Doctors and your healthcare agent use it when you can't decide for yourself. Written choices take guesswork away from the people you name, and in some states they shape what an agent may decide.

What Does a Living Will Cover?

It usually covers three decisions: whether to receive treatment meant to prolong life, whether to receive food and water through a tube, and whether to donate organs and tissue. Many forms also ask about pain relief.

An Advance Healthcare Directive (also called an Advance Directive) is a legal document that names someone to make medical decisions for you if you can't, and records the care you want. The person you name is your healthcare agent; the instructions part is often called a Living Will. Other terms:

  • Life-prolonging treatment: care that keeps the body going without reversing the underlying condition, such as CPR, a breathing machine, or dialysis.
  • Artificial nutrition and hydration: food and water given through a tube or IV rather than by mouth.
  • Comfort care: treatment aimed at pain and other symptoms rather than at extending life.

According to Mayo Clinic, an Advance Directive can cover choices about treatments such as tube feeding, along with pain management and organ donation.

Why Write Choices Down If You Have a Healthcare Agent?

Because your agent's job is usually to decide as you would, and your written words are the clearest evidence of that. An agent generally turns to their own sense of your best interests only where your wishes aren't known.

Without written choices, your agent has to reconstruct your wishes while talking with doctors, sometimes quickly. Declining a treatment for someone is also easier to carry when that person said so clearly, in their own words.

What Should a Living Will Say About Life Support?

It's usually easier to think in situations than in machines. Many forms ask what you would want if you had an incurable condition or were permanently unconscious.

Questions that tend to help:

  1. What makes extra time worth having to you: awareness, recognizing family, being free of pain?
  2. Would you accept a breathing machine or dialysis as a short trial, and stop if it doesn't help?
  3. Do you want the most pain relief available, even if it might shorten your life?
  4. Are there religious or moral beliefs your agent and doctors should know?

Saying no to life-prolonging treatment is not saying no to care. Pain relief is a separate choice, and many forms treat it separately.

Should You Put Tube Feeding in a Living Will?

Often, yes. Many people feel differently about tube feeding than about other treatments, and some state laws treat it differently too.

The useful distinction is time and purpose. A feeding tube used for a few weeks during recovery is a different decision from long-term tube feeding when recovery isn't expected, so it helps to say which situations your choice covers. According to Mayo Clinic, it helps to decide whether, when, and for how long you would want tube feeding.

How Does Organ Donation Fit in an Advance Healthcare Directive?

Most of an Advance Healthcare Directive guides care while the person who signed it is alive. Organ donation is the exception: a donation takes effect after the donor dies.

  • Donation can require staying on machines for a short time. It helps to address this in your instructions, so a "no life support" choice and a "yes" to donation don't appear to conflict.
  • Many states also offer a donor registry or a driver's license notation. Keeping your answers consistent avoids confusion.

Where Is Each Decision Recorded?

Some decisions live in your directive. Others are recorded somewhere else, or are left to your agent.

Decision Where it's recorded Who acts on it When it applies
Life-prolonging treatment, tube feeding Your directive's instructions Your agent and doctors When you can't make your own decisions
A situation your directive doesn't cover Not recorded anywhere Your healthcare agent, based on what they know of you When you can't make your own decisions
CPR and emergency treatment A POLST or DNR order signed by a clinician Emergency and care teams Once signed, as a current medical order
Organ donation Your directive, a donor registry, or your license Hospital and donation staff, sometimes your agent After the donor dies

A POLST (Physician Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment, called MOLST in some states) is a medical order a clinician signs, usually for someone seriously ill. A DNR is an order not to attempt CPR. Neither replaces a directive, but emergency teams often look to these orders first.

A directive also has nothing to do with property or probate, the court process for settling an estate. A Will takes effect after the person who made it dies, so it can't guide medical care.

Who Can Act on Your Choices, and When?

You can, as long as you can make your own decisions. Your agent usually steps in once a doctor determines you can't, unless your document lets the agent act right away.

  1. While you can decide, you speak for yourself and can usually change or revoke the directive.
  2. Once you can't, your agent decides, following your written choices.
  3. If your agent isn't available, an alternate you named steps in.
  4. If you named no one, state law often leaves the decision to family.

Who Should You Talk to Before You Decide?

Your healthcare agent first, since they will carry out the choices, then your doctor, and close family so the choices aren't a surprise. According to Mayo Clinic, talk with family members and other important people about your directive and your wishes. Bring the questions above to a doctor's appointment if you'd like the medical details explained.

Where Should an Advance Directive Be Kept?

Keep it where the people who need it can reach it quickly, and give them copies ahead of time. Many forms tell signers to give copies to their doctor, other providers, any facility where they receive care, and their agents.

It also helps to keep the original somewhere findable rather than locked away, tell your agent and alternates where it is, and review it after a major diagnosis, a move, or a change in who you'd name.

How This Varies by State

  • Tube feeding. In some states, an agent's authority over artificial nutrition and hydration depends on whether your wishes about it are known, so writing them down matters most here.
  • Form structure. Some states use one combined document. Others use a separate healthcare proxy and Living Will, and some recognize only one.
  • When the agent steps in. Many forms say authority begins when a physician determines you can't decide, unless you choose otherwise.
  • Signing. Witness and notary rules differ by state. See our guide to Advance Directive signing.

How these rules apply to you depends on your state and situation, which an attorney licensed in your state can address.

Common Questions

Can my healthcare agent override what I wrote in my Advance Directive?

Generally, no. A healthcare agent's role is to carry out your written instructions and known wishes, using their own judgment mainly where the document is silent. If you want your agent to have more room, you can say so in the document.

Is a Living Will the same as an Advance Directive?

Not always. In some states, one Advance Directive names an agent and records instructions. In others, a healthcare proxy names the agent and a separate Living Will records instructions. The names vary by state.

Does an Advance Directive from one state work in another state?

Often, but not always. Some states honor a directive that was valid where it was signed, and others have their own requirements. If you spend significant time in more than one state, the National Institute on Aging suggests preparing a directive using each state's form and keeping a copy in each place.

Can I change my Advance Directive after signing it?

Yes, while you can still make your own decisions. Most states let you revoke or replace a directive. After a change, tell your agent and doctors, and make sure the new version replaces the old one in your medical file.

What if I'm not sure what I want yet?

You can name an agent and leave some instructions blank. Your agent then relies on what they know of you, which is why conversations matter. In some states, an agent's authority over tube feeding depends on whether your wishes about it are known, so that choice is worth discussing even if you don't write it down.

Do I need an Advance Directive to have a DNR order?

No. According to Mayo Clinic, you don't need an Advance Directive or Living Will to have do-not-resuscitate or do-not-intubate orders. A DNR is a medical order a clinician signs, while an Advance Directive is your own document naming an agent and recording your choices. Many people have both.

Related reading:

About Dandelion and this article

Treatment choices only help if the people acting can find them. Dandelion helps you name a healthcare agent and record your Advance Healthcare Directive, and keeps it, with a note of who has copies, in your Family Playbook so your family can find it. Start my plan.

Dandelion is personalized, step-by-step estate and legacy planning for families, bringing legal paperwork, practical details, and personal keepsakes together in one shareable plan.

Love, with instructions.

Dandelion is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. State laws vary. For advice specific to your situation, consult a qualified estate planning professional.

Sources

As it turns out, peace of mind feels pretty good.

Start my plan4.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot